Carla CobiaCarla Cobia:
Several of the cookies had mold on them. 5 out of 12 were inedible. So for the price- this was a rip off. What ones were edible were decent. But this was way too expensive to get half the cookies to not be edible.
*UPDATE*
After speaking to customer service with the brand, they offered a full refund of the product and were very kind and apologetic about the situation. More than willing to give them another chance.
United States on Dec 15, 2023
AC:
I was pleasantly surprised at how prompt the company was in sending the cookies. They arrived in a box with a printed bow-tie on it and when opened, each cookie was individually wrapped. This was one gift for my husbands birthday as he loves the black and white cookie. I actually tried one for breakfast and it was yummy! The white side was lemony and chocolate side was quite fudgy. I never was a fan of these cookies before, but now I’m a convert. I may have to get some for myself….just sayin’
United States on Dec 12, 2023
Flannery Abrahamson:
When I was little, my dad used to take me to get these Black and White cookies at a little bakery near Ghent in Norfolk, VA on Saturdays. The bakery is not around any longer but I’m so glad I found that I can buy these cookies and they are still made just like I remember them tasting, smelling, and feeling! The old bakery used to make them a little bit larger in size but I’m also bigger now and everything is always bigger in your childhood memories!
My dad and I would eat these cookies after enjoying a movie at the Naro theater or a trip to the Chrysler Museum.
What I wouldn’t give to have my Da by my side enjoying one of these cookies again. These cookies were a nice treat to enjoy with my boys and tell them stories of how their Granddad got me to spin a Calder mobile as he stood on the sidelines as the museum guard tried to find my parent so we could be escorted out of the museum. Fun times!
United States on Oct 04, 2023
AB:
Love the chocolate cake…just not enough creamy icing centre.
Canada on Jun 21, 2023
Rebecca morrison:
Taste great
Canada on Jun 02, 2023
James C Young:
I’m a huge fan of the famous NYC Black & White cookie. I had my very first one when I was around 16yrs old. I’ve bought similar versions of these from local stores and cookie and cake shops and they never have that same flavor to them as the ones you can only buy in NYC. I don’t know if it’s the water or what, but I have never had one that is as good as an authentic NYC made Black & White. These are especially good and they may seem like they are a little expensive, but they’re worth every single penny they cost. Extremely made to perfection and a lot of pride went into these delicious treats. Not everyone loves these or even likes them, but for the ones that do love them, like myself, these were a great example of how to make the perfect Black & White cookie.
I was just amazed how much better and authentic these were compared to the ones that I have found locally. No, it’s not just my imagination, or that you can get three bags of Oreos for the cost, it’s just like the Beignet is to New Orleans and Cafe du Monde. It’s either a secret ingredient that NYC bakers have kept for years now or it’s the water they use. The texture is...
United States on Apr 15, 2023
Deanne Etherington:
These are EXACTLY the black and white cookies I was looking for. Taste and texture is perfect. Individually wrapped in a simple gift box.
Canada on Mar 17, 2023
Very disappointed in the lack of response to my request to see what we can do, to rectify this situation. Haven’t heard anything one month later. - too late now!!:
They tasted sour like the cream was off. Amazon won’t allow this item to be returned so we chucked them in the trash at our expense. Don’t buy them
Canada on Aug 29, 2022
Travis Fedak:
It was very very well packaged and so tastey
Canada on Jan 02, 2022
| Stern's Bakery Delicious Whoopie Pie Gift Basket - Perfect for Any Occasion! | LeilaLove Macarons: Indulge in 16 Delicious Valentine's Day Treats! | Leilalove Parisian Macarons Gift Box - 15 Delicious Mademoiselle de Paris Treats | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
 |
 |
|
| B2B Rating |
69
|
98
|
97
|
| Sale off | $2 OFF | $5 OFF | $4 OFF |
| Total Reviews | 44 reviews | 351 reviews | 538 reviews |
| UPC | 033454010141 | ||
| Package Dimensions | 10.67 x 9.57 x 1.93 inches; 1.76 Ounces | ||
| Manufacturer | Stern's Bakery | ||
| ASIN | B08PHFZNBY |
United States on Dec 20, 2023