Top 10 best Buffalo Wing Sauces products

Based on 827 reviews
Home > Grocery & Gourmet Food > Buffalo Wing Sauces

How to Choose the Buffalo Wing Sauces

Buffalo Wing Sauces: A Flavorful Journey Through Spicy Delights

Buffalo Wing Sauces

Buffalo wing sauces have enamored the palates and won the affection of individuals worldwide. This renowned sauce, celebrated for its impeccable fusion of zesty and savory notes, has firmly established itself as an essential component of American gastronomy. Whether you prefer your wings on the milder side or crave scorching spiciness, there exists a Buffalo wing sauce to cater to every taste preference. In this piece, we will embark on an extensive exploration of the historical roots, diverse range, and cultural importance of Buffalo wing sauces.

The Origin Story

The Buffalo wing sauce's roots can be found in Buffalo, New York, during the early 1960s. Many attribute the creation of this iconic sauce to Teressa Bellissimo, a co-owner of the Anchor Bar. Legend has it that she devised it as a late-night treat for her son and his friends. She achieved this by deep-frying leftover chicken wings and coating them with a homemade concoction crafted from hot sauce, butter, and a handful of undisclosed spices. This uncomplicated yet brilliant fusion sparked a culinary phenomenon that rapidly proliferated throughout the United States and around the world.

The Key Ingredients

Buffalo wing sauce, at its essence, comprises a select few fundamental elements:

  • Hot Sauce: The cornerstone of Buffalo sauce lies in hot sauce. The most commonly used hot sauce is Frank's RedHot, although various other options are accessible, each boasting its distinct flavor profile and level of spiciness.
  • Butter: The presence of butter is indispensable in crafting the sauce's opulent and velvety foundation. It serves to counterbalance the fiery kick of the hot sauce and contributes a sumptuous, smooth texture.
  • Additional Seasonings: While hot sauce and butter constitute the primary components, many renditions of Buffalo wing sauce incorporate supplementary spices and seasonings. These can encompass a spectrum of ingredients such as garlic powder, paprika, Worcestershire sauce, and vinegar, introducing complexity and depth to the overall flavor.

Variety of Flavors

The versatility of Buffalo wing sauces is truly remarkable. There's a vast array of flavors and heat levels available to cater to your individual taste. Here are some popular alternatives:

  • Mild Buffalo Sauce: Perfect for those who enjoy a touch of spiciness without the intense heat. It strikes a delightful balance between tangy hot sauce and creamy butter.
  • Medium Buffalo Sauce: A step up from mild, this sauce delivers a bit more of a spicy kick while remaining manageable for most people.
  • Hot Buffalo Sauce: Tailored for the heat aficionados, hot Buffalo sauce offers an intense, fiery experience that might have you reaching for a glass of water – or more wings!
  • Honey Buffalo Sauce: By melding the sweetness of honey with the spiciness of Buffalo sauce, this variety creates a delectable sweet and spicy contrast that's a favorite among many.
  • Garlic Parmesan Buffalo Sauce: Adding a burst of flavor to the traditional recipe, this sauce incorporates garlic and Parmesan cheese, resulting in a rich and savory option.
  • Asian-Inspired Buffalo Sauce: With the infusion of soy sauce, ginger, and other Asian seasonings, this Buffalo sauce brings an international twist to your wings.

Cultural Significance

Buffalo wings and the accompanying sauces hold a significant place in American culture, particularly in the United States. They are a fixture at sports bars, tailgate gatherings, and any occasion where delicious food and enjoyment intersect. Notably, the Super Bowl has transformed into a day of indulgence in Buffalo wings, with millions of pounds of chicken wings devoured throughout the game. Furthermore, Buffalo wing eating competitions have gained popularity as a spicy yet entertaining spectacle.

Outside of the United States, Buffalo wing sauces have transcended borders and entered the realm of international cuisine. Numerous countries now offer their unique interpretations of Buffalo-inspired dishes, tailored to local tastes and preferences.

Things To Consider When Buying Buffalo Wing Sauces

Whether you have a penchant for classic chicken wings, opt for cauliflower bites, or explore other wing alternatives, the importance of selecting the perfect buffalo wing sauce cannot be overstated. When it comes to purchasing buffalo wing sauces, there are several crucial factors to take into account.

Spiciness Level

When in the market for buffalo wing sauces, the first aspect to ponder is their spiciness level. Buffalo sauce is renowned for its fiery zest, and this spiciness can range from mild to intensely hot. Examine the product label or description for information regarding the Scoville heat scale or other heat indicators to gauge the sauce's spiciness. Ensure that your choice aligns with your heat tolerance and the preferences of those you'll be serving. For milder options, seek descriptions like "mild," "sweet and mild," or "mildly spicy." For those seeking a more intense experience, opt for "hot," "extra hot," or "fiery" sauces.

Flavor Profile

Buffalo wing sauces are available in a myriad of flavor profiles that go beyond the traditional hot and spicy. Some sauces offer a complex blend of flavors, adding depth to the classic buffalo taste. Consider whether you favor the classic buffalo flavor, desire something smoky, tangy, garlicky, or perhaps a sweet and spicy combination. Many brands provide unique variations of traditional buffalo sauce, so take the time to explore these different flavor profiles to find your preferred one.

Ingredients

It is always advisable to scrutinize the ingredients list when procuring buffalo wing sauce. High-quality sauces are crafted from natural ingredients and avoid artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. Opt for sauces featuring a concise and easily identifiable list of ingredients. Typical components in buffalo wing sauce encompass hot peppers (such as cayenne or jalapeño), vinegar, butter, garlic, and various spices. If you have dietary restrictions or allergies, be sure to scan for ingredients that may pose problems for you or your guests.

Consistency

The consistency of buffalo wing sauce can diverge from one brand to another. Some sauces are more fluid, resembling traditional hot sauce, while others are thicker and akin to a glaze. Your preference for consistency should be dictated by your intended use of the sauce. Thin sauces are ideal for drizzling over wings or dipping, while thicker ones work well for coating and baking.

Brand Reputation

The reputation of the brand is a significant factor in choosing buffalo wing sauces. Established brands with a track record of producing high-quality products tend to offer more consistent and dependable choices. You can also refer to customer reviews and ratings to gain insights into other consumers' experiences with a particular sauce. Online shopping platforms and social media can be valuable sources for learning from those who have already sampled the product.

Size and Packaging

Buffalo wing sauces are available in various bottle sizes and containers. Take into consideration your usage requirements and available storage space when selecting the size. If you intend to use the sauce frequently, a larger bottle may be more economical over time. Moreover, inspect the packaging for practicality. Some sauces come in squeeze bottles, while others use conventional glass or plastic containers.

Dietary Preferences

Buffalo wing sauces are formulated to cater to a wide range of dietary preferences. You can find options that are gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, and even keto-friendly. If you have specific dietary needs, make sure to examine the labels and choose sauces that align with your criteria.

Making Your Own Buffalo Wing Sauce

Although bottled Buffalo wing sauces are readily available in most grocery stores, creating your own at home is uncomplicated and enables you to customize the flavors to your preference. Below is a fundamental recipe to help you begin:

Ingredients

  • 1/2 cup of hot sauce (such as Frank's RedHot)
  • 1/3 cup of unsalted butter
  • 1 teaspoon of white vinegar
  • 1/4 teaspoon of Worcestershire sauce
  • 1/4 teaspoon of garlic powder
  • A pinch of cayenne pepper (optional, for added spiciness)

Instructions

  1. In a saucepan, gently melt the butter over low heat.
  2. Stir in the hot sauce, white vinegar, Worcestershire sauce, garlic powder, and cayenne pepper (if you desire more heat).
  3. Continue heating the mixture until it's thoroughly combined, stirring regularly.
  4. Once the sauce is heated and well-mixed, remove it from the heat source, and it's ready to be drizzled over your favorite cooked chicken wings.

Buffalo wing sauces stand as a testament to the enchantment that occurs in a kitchen when basic ingredients merge with innovation. Whether you prefer them mellow or blazing, conventional or with a distinctive spin, these sauces have left an indelible imprint on the culinary landscape, consistently delighting countless gastronomes across the globe.

If you're looking for a way to add flavor to your meals while also promoting your health, Buffalo wings sauces are a great option. With a wide range of brands and flavors to choose from, finding the right sauce for you can be a challenge. To make sure you get the best product for your needs, check out our featured section. Here, we review and recommend leading Buffalo wings sauces based on their flavor, performance, and ease of use.
1

Frank's RedHot Original Buffalo-Style Wing Sauce

98
123 reviews
Pros
  • The sauce has natural ingredients that offer a rich and buttery flavor
  • Kosher, vegetarian, and free of dairy ingredients makes it healthy
  • Spicy and bold flavor can add to everything from wings to dips and dressings
Cons
  • May be salty in taste
2

The New Primal Hot Buffalo Dipping & Wing Sauce: A Noble Flavor Experience

95
157 reviews
Amazon
$1 OFF
Pros
  • The buffalo sauces are dairy free and vegan making it healthy
  • Gluten-free that makes it safe for people with gluten allergy
  • Made with natural ingredients that makes it healthy and delicious
Cons
  • The bottle may cause leakage
3

2-Pack No Dairy Buffalo Sauce by Primal Kitchen - Whole 30 Approved, Keto & Paleo Certified

92
61 reviews
Pros
  • Made with avocado oil, cayenne sauce, and spices that makes it delicious
  • A feisty condiment for wings, burgers, cauliflower bites, and more
  • The sauce has no xanthan gum that makes it healthy
Cons
  • May not be suitable for people with tree nut allergy
4

Tantalizing Honey BBQ Sauce by Buffalo Wild Wings - 12 Fluid Ounce Bottle

91
14 reviews
Amazon
$1 OFF
Satisfy your sweet and smoky cravings with Buffalo Wild Wings Honey BBQ Sauce! This delicious sauce is made with the perfect blend of honey and BBQ flavors, creating a taste that is sure to please. This 12 fluid ounce pack of 2 is great value for money, and is one of the best Buffalo Wing Sauces on the market due to its versatility, flavor, and quality ingredients. Try it today and enjoy the rich, succulent flavor of Buffalo Wild Wings Honey BBQ Sauce!
5

Sweet Baby Ray's 64 Oz. Mango Habanero Wing Sauce & Glaze

90
79 reviews
Sweet Baby Rays Mango Habanero Wing Sauce & Glaze 64 Oz. (1-Pack) is a great choice for your next meal. This sauce is made with a combination of mango, habanero peppers, and other spices, giving it a unique and flavorful taste. Its versatility makes it perfect for wings, chicken, pork, seafood, and vegetables. It has a great value for money and is made with quality ingredients that make it taste delicious. With Sweet Baby Rays Mango Habanero Wing Sauce & Glaze 64 Oz. (1-Pack), you can enjoy a delicious meal with a unique flavor.
6

Creamy Parmesan and Garlic Sauce from Buffalo Wild Wings

88
12 reviews
Enjoy the delicious taste of Buffalo Wild Wings Parmesan Garlic Sauce with this 2-pack of 24 oz bottles! This award-winning sauce is renowned for its versatility, value for money, flavor, and ingredients. With its unique combination of Parmesan and garlic, it's no wonder why it's one of the best Buffalo Wing Sauces around. Get your hands on this 2-pack of 24 oz bottles and experience the delicious, one-of-a-kind taste of Buffalo Wild Wings Parmesan Garlic Sauce today!
7

Southern-Style White Dipping Sauce from Alabama - Perfect for Dipping!

87
52 reviews
Pros
  • Comes with a distinctive and zingy taste that can evoke the taste buds
  • Multi-purpose sauce that is suitable for grilled chicken, fried green tomatoes, french fries and more
  • Made with natural ingredients like soybean oil, water, sugar, distilled and cider vinegar and more
Cons
  • May have a sour taste
8

Frank's RedHot Original Cayenne Pepper Sauce for Buffalo Wings

86
10 reviews
Pros
  • Infused with red hot sauce that gives a delicious taste
  • The sauce are suitable with wings, drumsticks, sliders and more
  • Made with Kosher ingredients that makes it safe for consumption
Cons
  • May not be easy to pour the sauce
9

Sweet Baby Rays Teriyaki Wing Glaze & Sauce

85
22 reviews
Amazon
$2 OFF
Pros
  • Made of sweet and savory ingredients that makes it great for wings and all proteins
  • The sauces are suitable for beef, shrimp, salmon and veggies
  • Comes in bulk size that makes it long-lasting
Cons
  • Seal may came loose
10

Tantalizing Barbecue Sauces from Buffalo Wild Wings - Perfect for Grilling!

84
11 reviews
Pros
  • The sauce is suitable for burger, chicken, pork and more
  • Ideal for dipping sauce that makes it ideal for meats and veggies
  • Comes in a pack of two that makes it suitable for big gatherings
Cons
  • May contain high content of salt

We present recommended products based on a selection of 21 items and a cumulative total of 827 reviews. To explore additional recommended products, simply click on the pagination text below.

Before you spend your money, check out our reviews. Every time.
Best2buy Newsletter
Don’t miss out on the hottest seasonal and trendy products. Subscribe to our newsletter today.
Don’t miss out on the hottest seasonal and trendy products. Subscribe to our newsletter today.