Amazon Customer: Looks nice from across the room. Lots of imperfections up close, but we don’t sit directly in front of the fireplace so it’s fine. Mine was missing a magnet on one of the doors so it doesn’t close all the way at the top. Again, only noticeable up close. I wish the base was different and without the curly pieces.
United States on Aug 04, 2023
Kathy: Only issue, the feet were way too long as noted in other reviews. I had them cut down and it fits flesh against the fire place.
United States on May 15, 2023
hollythernhollythern: The screen came as described. It’s of nice quality. Super easy and quick to assemble. The screen was about a half an inch too wide leaving it sticking out a bit too far. I was able turn the back braces to make the screen sit further in the fireplace which made it look nicer to me. There are areas in the screen, as you may notice, that looks like the paint didn’t get evenly distributed. I’m giving it four stars because that seems like a flaw but doesn’t bother me all that much. Considering it is a very affordable screen.
United States on Aug 09, 2022
Jeremy D.Jeremy D.: We bought the gold screen, there is a reason it’s priced as low as it is. As many other reviews state, the feet on the backside of the screen are way too long and create too large of a gap from the fireplace to screen. My screen was also missing a bolt hole...on one of the feet the top hole for the bolt just hadn’t been drilled all together.
The gold finish is certainly just spray paint over a black (presumably spray painted) finished screen. It was obvious because the mesh parts only had gold paint on them along where the solid metal parts were sprayed, and the centers were still black. It looked absolutely terrible. (Sorry forgot to take a before pic)
I drilled out the missing hole without issue.
I used a cutoff wheel on an angle grinder and cut 3.75” off of the rear feet on each side (about half of their length). It’s still very stable and sits much closer (see pics).
I got some brass finish spray paint, taped off all the solid metal parts, and resprayed the front of the mesh to make a consistent finish.
After this, it looks much much better and I’m still into it for less than 1/3 of the cost of similar “nicer” brass finished fireplace screens.
United States on Feb 07, 2021
44x33in Handcrafted Wrought Iron Decorative Mesh Geometric Fireplace Screen - Best Choice Products | Amagabeli 3-Panel Pewter Wrought Iron Fireplace Screen - Foldable Cover for Wood Burning Fireplaces - Large Size | Classic 3-Panel Wrought Iron Fireplace Screen - 55x33in - Keep Your Hearth Protected | |
---|---|---|---|
B2B Rating |
91
|
98
|
98
|
Sale off | $10 OFF | $5 OFF | |
Total Reviews | 121 reviews | 176 reviews | 222 reviews |
Material | Iron | Wrought Iron, Metal | Iron |
Product Dimensions | 44.5"L x 33"W | 49.6"L x 28.9"W | 55.5"L x 33"W |
Best Sellers Rank | #35,428 in Home & Kitchen #7 in Fireplace Screens | #520,256 in Home & Kitchen #182 in Fireplace Screens#117,323 in Home Décor Products | #84,706 in Home & Kitchen #22 in Fireplace Screens |
Style | Mid-Century Modern | Petwer Leaves | Rustic |
Color | Black | Pewter | Black |
Item Weight | 17 pounds | 5 Kilograms | 11 pounds |
Brand | Best Choice Products | AMAGABELI GARDEN & HOME | Best Choice Products |
Manufacturer | Best Choice Products | AMAGABELI GARDEN & HOME | Best Choice Products |
Date First Available | November 14, 2019 | October 31, 2020 | |
Customer Reviews | 4.3/5 stars of 1,046 ratings | 4.7/5 stars of 2,352 ratings | 4.7/5 stars of 2,676 ratings |
Finish Type | gold | Powder Coated | Powder Coated |
Item Weight | 17 pounds | 5 Kilograms | 11 pounds |
ASIN | B081JPD9D6 | B015NRQ8GE | B08MBGN8C7 |
hayden d henry md: everything was fine
United States on Sep 19, 2023