McClure's Garlic & Dill Pickles - Tangy, Refreshing Taste for the Perfect Snack!

Laura: We have had these pickles several times. We ordered a jar as a gift. So disappointing- the pickles were soft & falling apart. The taste was sour & unpleasant. Mushy and sour as opposed to the fresh and crunchy pickles we normally enjoy.

United States on Dec 26, 2023

N S: These are a treat in my house! So delicious and tart! I had some sent to a friend and she loved them too! First saw about this company on Food Network years ago. Not your everyday pickle, good for a special treat every once in a while. Made me pucker!

United States on Sep 19, 2023

Patricia: The taste was very good, the only thing that prevented me from giving it a higher rating was I ordered it July 26 and didn’t arrive until Aug 6 with 2 day Prime! That’s a crazy amount of time for a jar of pickles. No where in the description did it say I had to wait for them to first grow the cucumbers .

United States on Aug 09, 2023

Bill M: I must first inform you that I ordered two jars of McLure’s garlic dill pickles. When my order arrived it was one jar of garlic dill and one jar of sweet and spicy, what I call bread & butter pickles. Don’t know if it was a boo-boo on your part, or if I got the last jar of garlic dill. At any rate I was super happy to learn how good the “bread & butter” were. Some times things happen got the better. That was the case in this instance. I have not tried the garlic dills as of this writing, but I am giving then five stars based on what I have tried. I strongly urge all pickle lovers to try McLure’s pickles. Maybe a bit pricey, but in the long run well worth the price when compared to your store shelf pickles. Yes, I recommend them highly, and will buy them again after my supply has run out. P.S. I only rate items when they are out of the ordinary and worth taking the time to do so. That tells you what I think of McClure’s pickles.

United States on May 25, 2019

E. Thomsen: These are good pickles. Despite being shipped in the middle of the summer and thus enduring summer heat until I could get them into my fridge, they are crisp. Ingredient list is nice and short, and nothing artificial. Quite tasty too.

So why do I only give them four stars, and state for many this is a five star product?

Personal preference. I know the label didn't say "kosher dill" but I was hoping for basically something similar to let's say (to use a national brand to keep things simple and due to my limited experience) a Claussen kosher dill, but without the additives that Claussen now has. (They don't have a lot, but they do have some, and Claussen even now adds a tiny bit of HFCS for some odd reason). The crispness is very much there, but these have for me a strong vinegar flavor first, then a small amount of garlic and dill. Take out most or all of the vinegar, and up the dill and maybe the garlic, and it would be five star for me. For those that like more of a "vinegary" flavor with a pickle, this is very much a five star product.

United States on Jul 10, 2013