Top 10 best Dessert Pies Review: Easy Sweet Fruit, Custard & Chocolate Pies for Parties & Potlucks products

Last Sunday after church, I swung by H-E-B thinking I’d just grab tortillas and dip. Next thing I know? I’m staring at the bakery section like, “Do I really need a whole pie?”

Short answer: yes. Always yes. 😌

But instead of grabbing store-made, I decided to try one of those Dessert Pies kits + ready-made options from Amazon (because I’ve been on this “let’s pretend I’m a baker” phase lately).

Y’all… this turned into a whole situation.

🥧 The Vibe Check

When the package showed up, I was low-key skeptical.

But honestly?

Not bad at all.

• Crust: Pre-made pastry / bread dough style (some kits include both options)

• Fillings: Sweet options like fruit, custard, chocolate

• Extras: Some came with toppings like whipped cream mix or sauce packets

Everything looked clean, organized, and surprisingly giftable—like something you could bring to a potluck and not feel embarrassed about.

On my granite kitchen island?
👉 Pinterest-core vibes, not struggle meal energy.

🔥 Real-Life Stress Test (Potluck Pressure Is REAL)

Setup: Family Potluck – 95°F Outside

I decided to make:

• 1 apple fruit pie

• 1 chocolate custard pie

Baking Time

• Prepped both in about 20 minutes total

• Baked at 375°F for ~35 minutes

Quantifiable moment:
Two full pies, done in under 1 hour, while I was also making arroz and checking TikTok 😅

The Taste Test 👀

Alright… this is what matters.

Apple Pie:

• Sweet but not overpowering

• Crust came out flaky (I was SHOCKED)

Chocolate Custard Pie:

• Smooth, rich, borderline dangerous

• Topped it with whipped cream = instant crowd favorite

👉 Compared to homemade-from-scratch pies?
Not quite abuela-level… but honestly? Pretty dang close for the effort.

😅 The “Oops” Moment

So… I didn’t fully seal the crust on the first pie.

Halfway through baking, the filling started bubbling out like it was trying to escape 😭

Had to clean the oven after. Not cute.

👉 Lesson learned:
Take 2 extra minutes to seal those edges properly. TRUST.

🌶️ The “Spicy” Truth

Let’s keep it honest:

1. You still gotta put in some effort
   This ain’t microwave-and-done. You’re baking, measuring a little, and paying attention.

2. Some fillings lean sweet-heavy
   If you don’t like sugary desserts, certain options (especially chocolate) might be too much.

🛒 What the Amazon “Neighbors” Say

After going through reviews, here’s the real consensus:

What people love:

• Super convenient for parties and potlucks

• Great variety of flavors (fruit, custard, chocolate)

• Good value compared to bakery pies

What people complain about:

• Instructions can be vague

• Some crusts need extra baking time

👉 Overall vibe:
People are pleasantly surprised—and keep reordering.

🤠 Who Should Skip This?

Let me save you a little money:

• If you ONLY want fully ready-to-eat pies → just hit the bakery

• If you’re super picky about “from scratch only” → this might not hit

• If you hate baking even a little → yeah… pass

🏁 The Final Verdict

Heck Yes.

These Dessert Pies (kits + ready options) are a solid middle ground between store-bought and homemade.

👉 Compared to bakery pies?
Slightly less perfect—but way more fun and customizable.

👉 Compared to full homemade?
Way easier, way faster, still delicious.

Perfect for:

• Family parties

• Potlucks

• Impressing people without stressing yourself out