Danielle BrooksDanielle Brooks: These are very warm winter boots. I bought them because I wanted something easy to slip on and off to head out in the snow with my kids but it’s not as easy for me to slip them on, wish there was some sort of tab or something on the back to grab to slip into, holding on to the fur makes it’s hard to grasp. The fit was true to my size. They are excellent for warmth. They are also really good for snow and even a bit good for snow/ice together but if it’s slippery out they aren’t as good as I would hoped, not as much grip if there isn’t any snow to stick too, but many boots are like that, I was just hoping for more traction on slippery surfaces. All and all a good boot.
Canada on Feb 19, 2021
countrysis: I live in the country and I'm in and out of the house a lot in the winter. I wear these every day basically. I can slip them on by just stepping in them. Sometimes with thicker socks I have to pull on but I dont normally wear thicker socks with these. They are fur lined the whole inside so pretty warm. I live in indiana so its normally 30 and wet in winter. I have walked through rain, snow and mud with these and they keep me dry. I have not submerged for long periods but have stepped in big puddles and still dry. Good traction in muck too. I bought a pair in 2019 and bought this pair a yr later so I could have a muddy pair and a pair for running errands. Now if I am inside somewhere very long with them , my feet sweat. Love these boots. They fit great. My feetbdont slide in them and they dont slip up and down. Even if I throw on without socks😖. I bought same size as I do for athletic shoes. My feet are normal to narrow and I am super picky with shoes. I have had problems with pain in my feet and these are pain free boots. When super dirty I just rinse them off.
United States on Jan 27, 2021
Julia M.: I ordered the size I usually wear and they fit perfectly. Good walking sole. My feet got a bit cold so they would t be good for an all day out door adventurer but to walk the dog and get in and out of the car, perfect. I love the slip on slip off aspect. Not good for deep snow as they are short
Canada on Jan 22, 2021
MacJAM: I bought these because my last pair of Columbia winter boots lasted almost 10 years. I bought a different brand for a similar price and was sorely disappointed when they were garbage after a little more than one year. Came back to Columbia and am really happy with these boots. They are warm, the size was exact, they are easy to put on and take off, they keep my feet dry, they help me stay upright on the walk to work on the slushy/icy sidewalks, they are great for playing in the snow with my child, I could go on and on about how much I love my new boots!
Edit: I am on year two of these boots and they are still warm. However, they are a pain to put on. The back of the boot is lower than the front and there is nothing to grab on to on the back to pull them on. I'm a little annoyed by them.
Canada on Jan 08, 2021
Amber .C: They look good on me which is nice. The material is very cheap and hard as a rock. Take me a long them to put my feet in which does not happen with my other boots before. Once they are in they are not too bad on comfort. I got them in a really good price so I guess you get what you pay for. They are not very warm so you have to wear thick socks with this boots for sure. If you care about looks more than the comfort than this pair boots has really good price tag. I can wear this for few hours a day just for the look but can't stand the hard material for too long.
Canada on Dec 02, 2020
CeliaCelia: I LOVE these boots! I've started to buy more Columbia products since my husband loves his Columbia hiking boots and is on his second pair. I ordered these and the exact same pair that comes with laces. After buying the laced pair, I thought that the laces would really bother my cold fingers (Raynauds). I was hesistant about these slip ons because all the reviews talked about how the foot opening was narrow and hard to get on. I tried both laced and slip on boots.
Laced (Columbia Ice Maiden II not pictured in this review)- These boots were not as cute as I had hoped and made me feel a little bit like a lumber jack. I appreciated that the laces gave me the room to loosen or make the boots tighter. They were extremely durable and warm.
Slip-Ons (Boots Pictured in this Review)- I would say that the opening isn't any smaller than any other slip on boot I've owned. I do also appreciate that the narrow opening around the ankle keeps cold air from rushing in. These are extremely thick, durable and warm. They definitely aren't a "fashion" boot but I would say they are pretty stylish for a real winter boot. I haven't tried them with super thick winter socks yet because my feet...
United States on Nov 19, 2020
loki: ok so I have not tried them out on ice yet, which is the deal maker or breaker as to whether I'll get them again, but as far as everything else, I did what any smart person does and went to STUPID OVERPRICED BRAND NAME store in the MALL and tried them on before buying them online. For much cheaper. They are SUPER comfy although a little tough to put on. I wish they had a zipper. The width is average, but easily accommodates my slightly wider feet. They are warm and I can't wait to see if they handle snow for the whole season. Will update .
Ok update: have worn them all winter and they really handled constant trudging through snow and rain. Your feet will not get wet at all. They are extremely well-insulated. They handle water so easily and you can wear them from the street to the shop without sweating so they are really versatile. The only thing that they do not handle at all is ice. They are TERRIBLE on ice. No traction. AT ALL. But this one thing has not prevented me from looking forward to buying more or more of the same for next winter. I doubt I will need to as they hold up extremely well. I think this boot is going to be my go-to boot going forward.( I also spent...
United States on Nov 22, 2015
ELL Teacher: When I purchased this, online reviews were only available for the lace-up version of this boot. (I only found one review on another site for the slip version, and it didn't answer any of my questions.) I was very excited to see that there was a slip-on version, as I will be very pregnant this winter and want to avoid tying any shoes. I received the boots today and am very pleased with them. What you should know is that the performance info and advice for the lace-up version are the same for the slip version. In summary: Like the lace-up boots, the slip boots are waterproof and are made to be used in temperatures as low as -25 degrees Fahrenheit and -32 degrees Celsius. Also, most people who reviewed the lace-up version recommended ordering a half size up; I followed this advice and the boots fit perfectly.
I live in the Boston area, and last year I didn't have good winter boots. I've been on a quest since then to find a boot that will keep my feet warm and dry in below-freezing temps, look good, and not break the bank. So far the Ice Maiden II looks like it might be the ONE. I'm looking forward to seeing how these boots perform this winter, and I will try to remember to...
United States on Oct 22, 2014
| Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Slip Winter Boot - Keep Feet Warm and Dry in Cold Weather | Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Slim-Fit Blue Jeans | Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Snow Boots - Keep Your Feet Warm and Dry in Cold Weather | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
 |
 |
|
| B2B Rating |
94
|
97
|
97
|
| Sale off | $4 OFF | $58 OFF | $58 OFF |
| Total Reviews | 1 reviews | 1 reviews | 4 reviews |
| Manufacturer | Columbia | No | Columbia |
| Department | womens | womens | Womens |
| Product Dimensions | 15 x 13 x 5 inches; 1 Pounds | 14 x 11 x 5 inches; 1.2 Pounds | 14 x 11 x 5 inches; 1.2 Pounds |
| Item model number | ICE MAIDEN II SLIP-W | 1554171 | 1554171 |
| Date First Available | September 17, 2014 | February 28, 2014 | February 28, 2014 |
| ASIN | B00H7WWN5E | B00GW97UO2 | B00GW97UO2 |
Canada on Aug 04, 2022