The Top 10 Eye Creams in 2023 for Combating Wrinkles, Fine Lines, and Dark Circles

The fragile and thin skin surrounding the eyes necessitates the use of an eye cream to shield against environmental damage caused by UV rays and pollution, as well as to alleviate signs of aging. An effective eye cream should also address issues like puffiness and dark circles.

In our quest to find the best products suited for various skin types, concerns, and budgets, we conducted thorough testing. Our team of testers diligently applied these eye creams for several weeks, evaluating factors such as texture, feel, ingredient composition, and how well each product lived up to its advertised benefits. We meticulously analyzed the results of our testing, incorporating them with additional research and consulting with a dermatologist to obtain expert recommendations.

Continue reading to discover which eye creams earned a spot in our final selection.

What’s The Best Eye Cream?

It depends on you and what your concerns are. There isn’t a one-product-fits-all answer. 
Given the myriad options of eye creams accessible in both physical stores and online, the difficulty lies in choosing the most suitable one. It is advisable to select a formula that incorporates ingredients specifically designed to target your primary concerns. Consider the following essential ingredients:

• Antioxidants: Antioxidants play a crucial role in shielding against cell damage and maintaining the sparkle in your eyes. Seek formulations with ingredients like vitamin C, vitamin E, and ferulic acid, known for their ability to counteract environmental damage. Antioxidants can effectively reduce swelling and puffiness, and vitamin C is renowned for its skin-brightening properties.
• Retinol: Embraced by dermatologists and beauty enthusiasts alike, retinol stands out for its proven efficacy. As a form of vitamin A, retinol stimulates collagen production, helping to diminish and prevent lines and wrinkles. It is a key ingredient to look for in anti-aging eye creams.
• Peptides: Peptides are a solution for addressing sagging, crepey skin around the eyes. They work by boosting collagen and elastin, contributing to the firming of sagging skin and preventing a paper-like appearance.
• Hyaluronic Acid and Ceramides: Given that the skin around the eyes is the thinnest on the body, it is prone to dryness and irritation. Combat this by opting for moisturizing ingredients such as hyaluronic acid and ceramides. Well-hydrated skin appears plumper, reducing the visibility of wrinkles.
• Niacinamide and Kojic Acid: Persistent undereye discoloration, even after a good night's sleep, may be attributed to genetics. Address this concern with niacinamide and kojic acid, which work by minimizing the activity of pigment-producing cells, resulting in brighter skin.
• Sunscreen: Regardless of age or concerns about wrinkles, the importance of sunscreen cannot be overstated. Whether using the same SPF applied to the rest of your face or opting for a product specifically designed for the eye area, don't overlook this step. Sunscreen is essential for protecting against skin cancer and sun damage.

Our Top Picks

BeautyStat Universal C Eye Perfector

This formulation, crafted by a cosmetic chemist, incorporates highly effective ingredients thoughtfully combined. Among them, vitamin C stands out, providing not only antioxidant defense but also promoting collagen production, thereby reducing the appearance of fine lines and enhancing skin tone. Remarkably, the formula features a 5% concentration of a pure, patented, and exceptionally stable form of vitamin C, complemented by CBD to address inflammation and puffiness.

In addition to these potent components, the product includes deeply hydrating elements such as hyaluronic acid and green tea extract, fostering collagen synthesis. Our testing revealed its efficacy as an excellent makeup primer, leaving the under-eye area instantly velvety-smooth. Over the three-week trial period, we observed a subtle decrease in fine lines and dark circles, along with a noticeable enhancement in skin texture and reduction in puffiness.

Pros:

• Plumps and softens the under-eye area
• Enhances skin texture
• Reduces puffiness and diminishes the appearance of dark circles

Cons: Slight tinging sensation

Estée Lauder Advanced Night Repair Eye Cream

Based on the brand's claim, this luxurious eye cream promises to illuminate dark circles within a mere two weeks, regardless of whether they exhibit blue/purple or brown undertones. In addition to addressing this concern across various areas such as under the eyes, eyelids, and inner corners, the cream combats the visibility of fine lines and dullness. This is achieved through a potent blend of skin-revitalizing ingredients, including hyaluronic acid, antioxidant vitamin E, and the brand's exclusive FR-Defense™ Technology. By enhancing hydration and plumping the under-eye region, the cream ensures that your eyes not only look more rested but also achieve a revitalized appearance immediately upon application.

Pros:

• Exceptional hydration
• Versatility in use
• A noticeable reduction in the appearance of tired eyes

Cons: Can cause irritation in individuals with sensitive skin.

The Ordinary Depuffing Eye Serum

Whether you've burned the midnight oil or indulged in one too many cocktails the previous night, a few drops of this eye cream hold the key to swiftly alleviating puffiness. It features a potent concentration of caffeine, a top-notch de-puffer renowned for its ability to constrict blood vessels. Additionally, it incorporates epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), an intense antioxidant derived from green tea leaves, further enhancing the formula's de-puffing capabilities. We're enthusiastic supporters of this formulation, and we've discovered that the synergistic blend of EGCG and caffeine is akin to a revitalizing cup of tea for your eyes—it revitalizes them, preparing them to meet the challenges of the day.

Pros: 

• Even a small amount has a significant impact
• Maintains effectiveness even with irregular use
• Contains a high concentration of caffeine

Cons: Might be drying for some

Ole Henriksen Banana Bright+ Eye Crème

The formulation is enriched with vitamin C for sustained brightening effects and collagen to enhance elasticity, maintaining skin's smoothness. A surprising inclusion in this blend is genuine gold, which aids in the efficient delivery of vitamin C to the deeper dermal layers. The formula also features hardy orange extract, contributing to the brightening of dark spots and amplifying the efficacy of vitamin C. Clinically demonstrated results within four weeks underscore the product's rapid action. Its lightweight, silky texture makes it perfect for application under makeup, and it incorporates color-correcting pigments to camouflage dark circles.

Pros:

• Feels lightweight
• Provides moisture
• Addresses wrinkles

Cons: May not be suitable for sensitive skin.

Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream

Numerous eye creams are available at the drugstore, and this stands out as one of the most potent choices. It features proven retinol, combined with a glucose complex designed to enhance the efficacy of retinol. Additionally, the powerful formula can diminish the appearance of crow's feet and improve the overall tone and texture of dry skin around the eyes, thanks to the inclusion of hyaluronic acid—our preferred hydrating ingredient. Notably, this formula is dermatologist-approved, providing reassurance for those concerned about using retinol in the eye area.

Pros:

• Adequate thickness to address crow's feet
• Enhances the skin's texture for a smoother appearance

Cons: Might be drying for some

La Prairie Skin Caviar Eye Lift Serum

The dual-phase serum combines encapsulated beads and a gel-cream emulsion, both infused with the renowned caviar extract from the brand. Ceramides are also incorporated into the formula to provide nourishment and enhance the resilience of the delicate skin surrounding the eyes. Reviewers have highlighted its lightweight feel, emphasizing that a single pump is sufficient to experience all the benefits. Its texture is particularly suitable for individuals prone to developing milia around the eyes. Upon testing the product, we were delighted to find that it imparted a supple and soft feel to the under-eye area while reducing the visibility of fine lines.

Pros:

• Firms the skin
• Feels lightweight
• Enhances skin smoothness

Cons: Pump delivery needs work

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Soothing Eye Cream

If your eyes are extremely sensitive, particularly during the challenging hayfever season, this mild eye cream can provide significant relief and hydration for delicate skin. Created by La Roche-Posay, its formula excludes typical irritants such as parabens, fragrance, and alcohol, making it suitable for those susceptible to reactions. The incorporation of niacinamide and mineral-rich spring water not only contributes to brightening the delicate skin around the eyes but also ensures a calming and moisturizing effect. Consequently, it stands as a crucial element in our skincare routines, especially amidst the summer months.

Pros:

• Moisturizing
• Gentle on sensitive skin and eyes
• Calms and soothes the skin

Cons: Small size

Kiehl’s Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado

We believe this eye cream is the ultimate hydrating solution—potent enough to double as an under-eye mask when generously applied. Whenever fatigue shows on our faces, a touch of this cream instantly revitalizes our appearance.

Its unique formula serves as an excellent primer for concealer, as confirmed by reviewers who appreciate its makeup-gripping properties. Infused with nourishing ingredients like avocado oil, shea butter, Beta-Carotene, Sodium PCA, and Copper PCA, it provides hydration without leaving a greasy residue on the delicate skin around the eyes (we recommend using a pea-sized amount). The enriching blend not only helps maintain moisture levels throughout the day but also illuminates the eye area while reducing puffiness.

A little product goes a long way, ensuring each jar lasts approximately six months.

Pros:

• Functions effectively as a makeup primer
• Provides excellent hydration
• Enhances skin brightness

Cons: Small size

Cetaphil Hydrating Eye Gel-Cream

A gel-based formulation is an excellent choice for individuals with oily skin or those who prefer an eye cream without a heavy sensation on the skin. Infused with a lightweight moisturizing agent, the formulation provides a skin-plumping effect and contains hyaluronic acid. We appreciate its fast absorption, leaving no sticky residue. Additionally, it boasts dermatologist-tested, ophthalmologist-tested, and hypoallergenic credentials, making it a suitable option for individuals with sensitive skin or eyes.

Pros:

• Non-greasy
• Non-irritating
• Quickly blends in

Cons: Flakes easily

Dr. Dennis Gross Skincare Triple Correction Eye Serum

This potent eye cream features a unique Phyto-Retinol Blend™, incorporating retinol, a renowned derivative of vitamin A known for its ability to effectively boost collagen production and smooth wrinkles. Complemented by ferulic acid, a standout antioxidant that guards against environmental damage, and bakuchiol, a milder retinol alternative enhancing collagen production and visibly diminishing fine lines. The remarkable aspect? It accomplishes all these benefits without causing any irritation. We appreciate the lightweight texture of this formula, sheer enough to be worn not only under and around the eyes but also on the lids.

Pros:

• Diminishes puffiness
• Calms the skin
• Easily absorbs into the skin

Cons: Might be drying for some

How To Use An Eye Cream

It is generally recommended to follow a sequence of applying skincare products from the lightest to the heaviest. After cleansing your skin and applying sunscreen, proceed with your eye cream before using your moisturizer. This order allows the ingredients in the eye cream to better penetrate the skin.

When applying the eye cream, it's important to be gentle. A small amount of the product is usually sufficient. Use your finger, preferably the ring finger, to delicately pat the cream around your eyes, avoiding any pulling or tugging on the skin.

To sum up, eye creams can be found across a spectrum of price ranges, from budget-friendly options to those that make you question if you're purchasing a small jar of lotion or liquid gold. The price tag doesn't necessarily correlate with effectiveness. Instead, seek out an eye cream that aligns with your specific eye care objectives and fits within your budget.